If you’ve ever worn shoes that are too big or too small, you know how uncomfortable that can be. Ill-fitting shoes can lead to foot pain, blisters, and even long-term foot issues. One solution that many people turn to is inserting insoles into their shoes.

But a question arises – how much will those insoles change the fit of your shoes? Will you need to buy shoes in a bigger or smaller size to accommodate insoles? In this comprehensive guide, we’ll cover everything you need to know about how insoles affect shoe size.

If you’re short on time, here’s the quick answer: Insoles can change your shoe size anywhere from 1/4 to a full size larger. The exact amount depends on the thickness and design of the insole. Most insoles add 1/4 to 1/2 sizes.

Full-length insoles and those with more arch support increase size the most.

What Are Shoe Insoles?

Shoe insoles, also known as footbeds or inserts, are removable cushions that are placed inside shoes to provide additional support, comfort, and protection to the feet. They are designed to fit inside the shoe and can be easily taken out and replaced as needed.

Insoles can be used to address various foot conditions, improve shoe fit, and enhance overall foot health.

Definition and purpose of shoe insoles

Shoe insoles are specially designed inserts that are placed inside shoes to provide additional support and cushioning to the feet. They are often used to address specific foot conditions such as high arches, flat feet, plantar fasciitis, and overpronation.

Insoles can help alleviate foot pain, provide better shock absorption, improve stability, and enhance overall foot comfort. They can also help improve shoe fit by filling any gaps or spaces inside the shoe, preventing the foot from sliding or moving around.

Types of shoe insoles (full, 3/4, heel)

There are different types of shoe insoles available in the market, each catering to specific needs and preferences. Full-length insoles extend the entire length of the shoe and provide support and cushioning from heel to toe. They are ideal for those who need overall foot support and comfort.

3/4-length insoles, as the name suggests, cover only the forefoot and arch area of the foot. They are suitable for people who require arch support or need extra cushioning in the front part of the foot.

Heel insoles focus primarily on providing cushioning and support to the heel area, which can be beneficial for those suffering from heel pain or plantar fasciitis.

Materials used for insoles

Insoles can be made from a variety of materials, each offering unique properties and benefits. Some of the common materials used for insoles include:

  • Memory foam: This material molds to the shape of the foot, providing customized support and cushioning.
  • Gel: Gel insoles offer excellent shock absorption and provide a cushioned feel under the feet.
  • EVA foam: Ethylene-vinyl acetate (EVA) foam is lightweight, flexible, and provides good shock absorption.
  • Arch support: Some insoles have built-in arch support, which helps to distribute pressure evenly across the foot and maintain proper foot alignment.

It’s important to choose the right type of insole and material based on individual needs and preferences. Consulting with a podiatrist or footwear specialist can help determine the most suitable option for specific foot conditions or concerns.

How Insoles Change Shoe Size

When it comes to shoe size, insoles can make a significant difference. They have the power to alter the fit and feel of footwear in several ways. Let’s explore some of the ways in which insoles can change your shoe size.

Thickness of insoles increases size

The thickness of insoles can directly impact the size of your shoes. Adding a thicker insole can make your shoes feel tighter and may require you to go up a size to maintain comfort. Conversely, if you have a shoe that fits slightly loose, a thinner insole can help fill the extra space and make the shoes fit better.

Arch height impacts fit

The arch height of insoles can also affect how your shoe fits. Insoles with a higher arch can provide additional support and stability, but they may take up more space inside the shoe. This can lead to a tighter fit and may require you to go up a half size or more to accommodate the increased height.

Heel cups can make heels tighter

Insoles with built-in heel cups are designed to provide extra cushioning and support to the heel area. While they can be beneficial for those with heel pain or discomfort, they can also make the shoe fit tighter around the heel.

If you plan on using insoles with heel cups, it may be necessary to size up to ensure a comfortable fit.

Length of insole (full vs 3/4)

The length of the insole can also impact shoe size. Full-length insoles extend from the heel to the toe, taking up more space inside the shoe. This can make the shoe feel tighter and may require you to go up a size.

On the other hand, 3/4 length insoles only cover the arch and heel area, leaving more room in the toe box. They may not affect the shoe size as much.

Rigidity of the insole material

The rigidity of the insole material can play a role in how it changes your shoe size. Softer, more flexible insole materials may conform to the shape of your foot and not significantly impact the size. However, stiffer materials may take up more space inside the shoe and make it feel tighter.

Consider the material of the insole when choosing the right size.

Remember, the impact of insoles on shoe size can vary depending on factors such as the brand and style of the shoe, as well as individual foot shape and size. It’s always a good idea to try on shoes with insoles before making a final decision.

Factors That Determine Size Change

When it comes to determining how much insoles can change your shoe size, there are several factors to consider. These factors can vary from person to person and can greatly influence the fit and comfort of your shoes.

Let’s take a closer look at some of the key factors that determine size change when using insoles.

Your foot size and shape

One of the most important factors that determine how much insoles can change your shoe size is your foot size and shape. Each person’s feet are unique, and the size and shape of your feet can greatly impact how much room you have inside your shoes.

Insoles can provide additional cushioning and support, but they may also take up some space inside your shoes. Depending on the thickness and design of the insoles, they can make your shoes feel slightly tighter or looser.

Type of shoe (lace-up, slip-on, boots, etc.)

The type of shoe you plan to use with insoles can also influence the size change. Different types of shoes have different constructions and designs, which can affect how much room there is for insoles.

Lace-up shoes, for example, may have more adjustability and allow for a greater size change compared to slip-on shoes. Boots, with their typically roomier fit, may have more space to accommodate insoles without significantly changing the size.

It’s important to consider the type of shoe you will be using insoles with to determine the potential size change.

Activity the shoes will be used for

The activity you plan to engage in while wearing shoes with insoles can also impact the size change. If you are using insoles for athletic activities such as running or hiking, you may want a slightly looser fit to allow for better movement and stability.

On the other hand, if you are using insoles for dress shoes that require a more formal and snug fit, the size change may be minimal. Consider the specific activity you will be using the shoes for to determine the desired size change.

Your personal comfort and preferences

Ultimately, your personal comfort and preferences play a significant role in determining the size change when using insoles. Some individuals may prefer a tighter fit, while others may want a more relaxed and roomy feel.

It’s important to try on different insoles and shoes with them to find the right combination that provides optimal comfort for you. Don’t be afraid to experiment and find what works best for your feet and overall comfort.

Choosing the Right Insole Thickness

When it comes to insoles, choosing the right thickness is crucial for optimal comfort and support. Here are some important factors to consider:

Measure foot size accurately

Before selecting insoles, it’s essential to measure your foot size accurately. Using a foot measuring device or visiting a shoe store with a professional fitting service can help you determine the correct size. This ensures that the insoles fit properly and provide the desired level of comfort.

Consider goals for insoles (comfort, support, etc)

When choosing insoles, it’s important to consider your specific goals. Are you looking for added comfort or extra support? Different insoles come with varying features, such as arch support, cushioning, or shock absorption.

Understanding your needs will help you select the right insole thickness that aligns with your goals.

Test insoles in shoes before wearing all day

Before committing to a particular insole thickness, it’s advisable to test them out in your shoes. Insert the insoles and wear the shoes for a short period, such as an hour or two. This will give you a better idea of how the insoles feel and whether they provide the desired level of comfort and support.

It’s better to make adjustments early on rather than discovering discomfort after wearing them all day.

Allow for an adjustment period as insoles compress

Keep in mind that insoles may compress over time, especially if they are made of foam or gel materials. This means that initially, an insole may feel thicker than intended. Give yourself an adjustment period to allow the insoles to settle and conform to your feet.

If you find that the insoles have compressed too much and no longer provide adequate support, it may be time to replace them.

Remember, finding the right insole thickness is a personal journey. Experiment with different options, consider your goals, and test them out before committing to wearing them all day. By taking these steps, you’ll be one step closer to finding the perfect insoles for your needs.

Tips for Getting the Best Shoe Fit with Insoles

Size up a 1/2 size when buying new shoes for insoles

When purchasing new shoes to accommodate insoles, it is recommended to size up by half a size. Insoles can take up extra space inside the shoe, so by choosing a slightly larger size, you ensure that your feet have enough room to fit comfortably with the added support.

This will prevent any discomfort or tightness that may arise from wearing insoles in shoes that are too small.

Shop late in the day when feet are most swollen

It’s a good idea to go shoe shopping later in the day when your feet are at their largest. Throughout the day, especially if you are on your feet for extended periods, your feet tend to swell. By trying on shoes in the afternoon or evening, you can ensure that you are getting the most accurate fit with insoles.

This will help prevent any potential discomfort or tightness that may occur when your feet are swollen.

Wear socks similar to those you’ll use with the shoes

When trying on shoes with insoles, it is important to wear socks that are similar to the ones you will be using with the shoes regularly. Different socks can affect the fit of the shoe, so wearing the appropriate socks during the fitting process will give you a better idea of how the shoes will feel when you wear them with insoles in your everyday life.

Try insoles in both left and right shoe

When testing out insoles in a store, it’s recommended to try them in both the left and right shoe. This will give you a better understanding of how the insoles feel and fit in each shoe, as sometimes there can be slight differences in size or shape that may affect the fit.

By trying them in both shoes, you can ensure that the insoles provide the same level of support and comfort on both feet.

Walk around the store with insoles in shoes

It’s important to take a few steps and walk around the store when trying on shoes with insoles. This will give you a better feel for how the insoles affect the fit and comfort of the shoes while in motion.

Walking around will help you determine if there are any pressure points or areas of discomfort that may arise when wearing the shoes with insoles for an extended period. It’s always better to test them out in the store before making a purchase.

Consider adjustable laces or straps for flexibility

If you plan on using insoles regularly, it might be worth considering shoes with adjustable laces or straps. This allows you to customize the fit of the shoe to accommodate the added thickness of the insoles.

By having the ability to adjust the tightness of the shoe, you can ensure a snug and comfortable fit even with insoles. This flexibility can greatly enhance the overall comfort and support provided by the shoes.


Insoles are a great way to improve the comfort and support of shoes that are slightly too big or too small. While the amount of size change varies, most insoles add between 1/4 and 1/2 shoe sizes. Pay attention to insole thickness, arch height, and length when choosing insoles.

Size up about 1/2 a shoe size when shopping for new shoes to accommodate insoles. With some trial and error, you can find the perfect combination of insole and shoe that keeps your feet happy and blister-free.

Similar Posts